25 September 2008

ch-ch-ch-ch-ch-ch-changes....turn and face the strain

The narratives, "The Victim of Seduction! Some Interesting Particulars of the Life and Untimely Fate of Miss Harriot Wilson" and "A Very Surprising Narrative of a Young Woman, Who Was Discovered in a Rocky Cave" show the changes in style of how women were portrayed in the major presses of the time, such as broadsides, during the late 1700's and early 1800's.

While Harriot Wilson was originally written in 1802 and Rocky Cave Lady in 1788, these two pieces show the emergence of a shift in how women were popularized in the time period.

Though Wilson is treated in a kinder fashion than some of her predecessors in the texts we have been studying, she ultimately has a date with the gallows for infanticide resulting from illegitimacy with a married man named Smith. The changes we see in Wilson's narrative is that the woman is not made out to be a bad person, but is rather placed on a higher plane. The narrator says, "The body of her new born infant was found secreted in a neighboring grove--the unfortunate Harriot was suspected and charged with being the perpetrator of the unnatural deed" (Wilson 5). She is not bastardized as a scraggly hoe, but Harriot's story is told with a noted level of respect.

The narrator also points out how Harriot is seen as a wise and learned woman by her teaching her friends to "Take warning of her fate, and to be ever on their guard against the intrigues and seducing arts of the other sex" (Wilson 6). This is the first time that we've seen a narrative that does not solely blame a woman for what has happened. The narrator writes, "Not until the credulous and unsuspecting Harriot had surrendered to her vile seducer" (Wilson 4).

The Panther Narrative is the first piece we've read that shows the change in woman subject from being killed at the end, to being a hero-type figure. This narrative was written when America was obsessed with the idea of westward expansion and catered to those readers who wanted to know what it was like to survive and thrive in the chaotic throws of uncivilization.

This heroine escapes her savage Indian captors after her eloped lover is killed and then she slays a giant Indian-eventually-black man who attempts to compromise her "business". She then lives in her multiple-roomed and Martha Stewart'ed cave for nine years before getting discovered, fortunately for her, by the man who was to eventually make her story famous through its publishing.

The narrative describes how she thrived on the land where she says, "I here found a kind of Indian corn, which I planted, and have yearly raised a small quantity. I here contented myself as well as my wretched situation would permit" (Panther 48). She enjoyed living in the wilderness and found the life to be of high quality and something she would have never gotten if she lived in the town. Upon initially being alone in the woods after her husband's death, she pondered returning, but the earth came to her rescue, "By day, spontaneous produce of the earth supplied me with food; by night the ground was my couch, and the canopy of heaven my only covering" (Panther 48).

She gives exciting detail in how she hatcheted her Indian seducer "with three blows, effectually put an end to his existence" (48). The piece gets risque just before the hatcheting when she describes his sexual advance as he "Motioned to me to lay myself beside him. I declined his offer, and at a length he rose in a passion" (48). This paragraph must be one of the main reasons this narrative was such a popular piece at the time, by having sex and death in close proximity of eachother.

The Panther Narrative and Harriot Wilson are two pieces which are notable for showing a more positive view of women given the history of other writings we have read. Harriot is at least respected and not fully blamed before she is killed, and most notably the Cave Woman is the first we've read about whose narrative doesn't end in the dead of the female, but instead entices the reader with tales of sex, murder and returning to the essence of her self.

2 comments:

Anonymous said...

he Justin,
I think you mention some very good points. The Panther Narrative is in deed very diffferent from the narratives we've read before.
This is the first time, that a woman becomes sort of a hero. She kills the giant Indian who tries to bring her to heel. Besides, she manages to live on her own in the wilderness. Apparently, she doesn't need male protection.

Dein Freund, Ole

Doe said...

I love it in this story that the woman in the Panther narrative is seen as an upstanding young woman that knows what she wants and is willing to do what it takes for it. She is not timid and understands that there will be consequences for going against her father's wishes.

Also, the narrative does include language that before this time, would have been shocking and obscene to the social reader!